<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Michael/Male/26-30. Lives in United States/Pennsylvania/Wexford/Christopher Wren, speaks English. Spends 20% of daytime online. Uses a Fast (128k-512k) connection. And likes baseball /politics.
This is my blogchalk:
United States, Pennsylvania, Wexford, Christopher Wren, English, Michael, Male, 26-30, baseball , politics.

Thursday, August 26, 2004

Is stealin' a crime?  

A few weeks ago, after I got done reading about how stolen bases were held in such disfavor by sabremetrics acolytes, I tried to figure out if the numbers supported their contention that stolen bases were counter-productive because they didn’t impact the game much and players caught stealing were “wasted outs”. I tested the numbers and discovered that, aside from the St. Louis Cardinals, the top run-scoring teams were the ones that didn’t try and played the station-to-station baseball so derided by practitioners of baseball’s conventional wisdom. Score one for the stat geeks.

I revisited the numbers and found that things had changed, a little:

1. Milwaukee: 130 attempts (98 successful; 75%)
2. St. Louis: 121 attempts (86 successful; 71%)
3. Los Angeles: 114 attempts (83 successful; 73%)
4. Montreal: 106 attempts (78 successful; 74%)
5. New York: 104 attempts (87 successful; 84%)
6. Florida: 96 attempts (66 successful; 69%)
7. Philadelphia: 94 attempts (75 successful; 80%)
8. Pittsburgh: 86 attempts (50 successful; 58%)
9. Houston: 85 attempts (60 successful; 71%)
10. Atlanta: 81 attempts (54 successful; 67%)
11. Chicago: 75 attempts (51 successful; 68%)
12. Cincinnati: 71 attempts (52 successful; 73%)
13. San Diego: 63 attempts (42 successful; 67%)
14. Arizona: 63 attempts (35 successful; 56%)
15. Colorado: 61 attempts (36 successful; 59%)
16. San Francisco: 50 attempts (33 successful; 67%)

At the risk of making a fairly obvious observation: the teams that don’t succeed don’t steal and teams that do succeed, try more. (Shocking, I know.) But were the teams stealing bases successful offensively? Well …

Top 5 Runs Scored:
1. St. Louis: 672 runs scored
2. San Francisco: 662 runs scored
3. Colorado: 658 runs scored
4. Philadelphia: 628 runs scored
5. Chicago: 606 runs scored

These five teams have been, fairly consistently, the best in the league in terms of scoring runs. Here again, the stat attack on CW holds up: the Rockies and Giants are the two worst NL West teams at base-stealing. And Chicago isn’t much better. The Phillies are fairly in the middle, and the Cardinals are the exception to the rule.

Now things get interesting ...

Bottom 5 Runs Scored:
16. Montreal: 484
15. Milwaukee: 497
14. Arizona: 498
13. Pittsburgh: 548
12. Florida: 549

Aside from Arizona, these five teams make up half of the eight teams that base-steal the most. The obvious correlation between the two bits of data are that teams that steal bases don’t score runs. But is that true? I noticed a few other things that threw a little cold water on my conclusions:

There is nothing wrong with successfully stealing a base. Who can argue that having a guy on second is worse than having him on first? Scoring position, no double-play, etc. The problem is with players caught stealing. Losing base-runners effectively lowers your on-base percentage, so you are best off not trying. The problem is, with 35 players caught stealing, the Cardinals waste base-runners like nobody’s business. They are second-worst after the Pittsburgh Pirates (36). And the Cardinals are first in the NL in runs. And the Cards are scoring more than Paris Hilton at a frat party. Which means:

1. Maybe losing 25-30 base-runners a season isn’t so bad to a team’s offense. Or,

2. Think how good the Cardinals would be if they stopped running on the base-paths. 1,000 runs easy.

But it is true that the Phillies, Rockies, Cubs and Giants, the other four top run-scoring teams, were also amongst the teams with the fewest base-runners caught stealing. Again, the Cards are the exception to the rule. Then I noticed … Montreal, Milwaukee, Arizona, Pittsburgh and Florida all ranked 11-15 in the NL in ISO (poor San Diego continues to bring up the rear in ISO). Along with San Diego, these teams ranked 11-16 in terms of slugging percentage. A stronger case can be built that lacking power in the lineup is a bigger … make that a much bigger ... factor than unsuccessful base-stealing.

Something to think about…

Comments:
Imagine Thousands Of Links Back To Your Web Site From Other People's Blogs!
 
And A Link Back To Your Web Site Excite You?
 
Think that will drive you some extra traffic?
 
Good comments. But, I do not agree with most of them. People sure have a lot of time on their hands.
 
Diet programs What are the major factors in developing obesity? Learn more. Please visit Diet programs
 
I have read your post and tend to lean towards your opinion also, however, there are lots of conflicting opinions online. Do you have any evidence to back this up?Thanks,RD Martinwebmastercolon cleansing in new orleans
 
weight loss How many calories do we need each and every day? Learn more. Please visit weight loss
 
low calorie diet Can you lose weight or were you born overweight? Learn more. Please visit low calorie diet
 
Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?